Column: Thank God Shoreham never opened

03/24/2011 11:03 AM |

BARBARAELLEN KOCH PHOTO | A glass etching at Hallockville Museum Farm in Northville shows how the northern horizon and adjacent farmland would have appeared had Long Island Lighting Co. been successful in its efforts to build nuclear power plants there.

The profoundly disturbing images coming out of Japan, coupled with news reports about the Indian Point Nuclear Power Plant on the banks of the Hudson River in Buchanan, N.Y., have got me thinking again about what might have been if the Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant had been allowed to operate.

In the case of Japan, American advisors have opined that nothing less than a 50-mile evacuation zone would be prudent. Translate that to Indian Point, which was built near two earthquake-prone geological faults, and you’re talking about 20 million people living within 50 miles. No way such an evacuation could ever be successfully accomplished.

The population within 50 miles of Shoreham is something less, because it’s about 65 miles from there to Manhattan, but the evacuation challenge would have been much greater because of the, pardon the expression, dead end that is the East End of Long Island. Transport Fukushima to Shoreham and you’re talking civil disorder and disarray like this nation has never seen.

There have been times since the end of the successful campaign to block the Shoreham plant when some may have wondered if the fight was worth it, particularly considering the generally excellent safety record of nuclear power plants in this country. This is not one of those times.
Oh, yes, Millstone. I almost forgot Millstone, which looms across Long Island Sound just eight miles from the North Fork. If the Millstone plant melts down, our only means of evacuation might end up being the Queens-Midtown Tunnel.

Earthquakes can hit anywhere but tsunamis wreak havoc only in coastal regions. Oops.

And the experts say Long Island is particularly vulnerable because, generally speaking, our shoreline is comparatively low. We have some imposing cliffs on the North Shore, but the South Shore would be steamrolled by a 30-foot-high wave. And if the tsunami originated in the open Atlantic, you can’t help but wonder if East Hampton, Southampton and Shelter Island towns would act as life-saving breakwaters for their neighbors on the North Fork.

If I seem a bit preoccupied this week, it is because I am. With March Madness, also known as the NCAA Division I Men’s Basketball Tournament. Ever since my college days, when I covered the sport for the Philadelphia Inquirer, I’ve been a college basketball nut.

It started out with heroes like Bill Bradley, Bob Lanier and Calvin Murphy and continues more than 40 years later with the likes of Kemba Walker, Nolan Smith and Jimmer Fredette, the most unlikely of hoop heroes from the most unlikely of home towns, Glens Falls, N.Y., whose only other meaningful basketball-related claim to fame is that it is the home of the New York State high school basketball championships.

In my book, college basketball is the No. 1 spectator sport, far surpassing baseball (too boring), football (too violent) and pro basketball, wherein overpaid and travel-weary manchilds dial up the college game’s every-day intensity only during the last minute of regular season games and the last quarter of playoff games.

From Thursday through Sunday of this past week, I ended up watching a portion of at least 20 college basketball games on television. (The former Joan Giger Walker passed salted peanuts and a refreshing beverage from time to time, but she was savvy enough not to attempt any meaningful conversations. All she would have received in return was a blank stare and a few indecipherable mumbles having to do with back door screens and vision-challenged officials.)

This orgy of televised college basketball was aided and abetted by two comparatively recent developments: the advent of digital video recording (DVR) technology, which allows fans like me to record games when our life partners thoughtlessly schedule dinner engagements or other annoying distractions opposite key basketball games; and the NCAA’s unprecedented decision to televise every game live on one of four separate networks, CBS, TBS, TNT and something I never heard of before called TRU.

Originally, there were 68 teams alive in this single-elimination tournament. Now there are but 16. And after this coming weekend, only the Final Four will remain.

Remember, you heard it here first: The aforementioned Final Four will consist of Ohio State, Duke, Florida and, surprise of surprises, Virginia Commonwealth.

And the 2011 NCAA national champions? Why, Duke, of course.

(Columnist’s note: Transmit your Final Four and national champion picks to me at [email protected] no later than 7:15 p.m. on Thursday, March 24, to be eligible for a prize too grand to specify here. Contestants will receive one point for each correct Final Four pick and two points for choosing the eventual national champion.)

[email protected]



10 Comment

  • Shoreham was closed on the Fiftieth Anniversary of the successful evacuation of a 500,000 man army from Dunkirk while under attack from the air and artillery, so don’t talk to us about a “dead end”. But ignorance and a “sky is falling” hysterical mentality prevailed over common sense. To equate Japan with Long Island’s North Fork is to ignore Geography and Physics to try to make a point. It was a disaster to close Shoreham, and still is.
    As for baseball – “boring”? Compared to twenty-somethings playing what has become a playground game of egotitistical individual chest beating and showboating (except for the women’s game), baseball remains a ballet – requiring more than an occasional snippet, but intense concentration.

  • yeah, because if the reactors right across the sound had a problem, the radiation wouldnt be able to cross the water and we’d all be safe.

  • I agree nuclear power plants are way too scary to justify their existence so close to inhabited areas.
    Let’s try wind or water power, or clean-burning coal.
    And my hat goes off to Joan Giger Walker Gustavson for being savvy enough to know when to avoid conversation in the “man-cave” during important events like March Madness. Unfortunately, not all of the final four were your picks, but one out of 4 ain’t bad I suppose.

  • How you can compare Japan to Long Island or anywhere on the east coast for that matter is way beyond me!!! Nuclear is the the cleanest and most efficient form of power in the world. If we abandon it then we are left with only oil and coal power plants, which are the biggest polluters in the world as we all saw in the gulf coast. Windmills and solar power will never produce enough power to satisfy our power consumption.

  • Troy – don’t know if you remember re: your Shoreham piece that A) the looney tunes at LILCO originally wanted to build six nuclear plants on the north fork and that B) during the controversy over the first of two planned reactors at Jamesport in the seventies, a test was done to see where radioactivity would travel if released. Baloons launched from the Jamesport site landed square in the middle of Southold. That was great to hear! A nuclear accident on the north fork would not have been as bad as Japan’s – it would have been worse – At least the people near the Japanese reactors can run from them. On the north fork, residents would have had no way to evacuate without first driving directly toward a plant in Shorham or Jamesport.

  • Due to the diminished brain power of the columnist, no contest entries were received by the very unreasonable 7:15 p.m. Thursday deadline. It should be pointed out, however, that he (the columnist) did pick VCU to reach the Final Four. And the championship game reminded him of a long-ago (before the shot clock and the demise of the four-corner offense) Penn v. Princeton game in which the final score was something like 35-29. He (the columnist) does not remember who won.

  • You are paying for Shoreham and not using it.You would be better off if it was up and running.