Where is the best pizza?
This is a hot button topic, but we want to know what you think… Where is the best pizza on Long Island? Let us know your favorite below.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Alzheimer’s Disease Resource Center hosted its eighth annual Walk for Alzheimer’s in Riverhead Saturday. Comments comments
For residents of Shelter Island, who regard Gardiners Island as a distant, somewhat mysterious cousin, there can be few guides…
Read More
Most children make friends by chatting in the classroom, on the playground or during after-school activities. But one Mattituck second-grader…
Read More
Lenny’s in Jamesport
Giuseppes in Huntington
pizzetteria brunetti in westhampton beach
http://www.pizzetteriabruneti.com
La Capricciosa Pizza in Greenport!
Village Pizza in Mattituck!
Caruso’s in Riverhead. After being away for 6 years, the first thing we did when we got there in September was order pizza at Caruso’s….it’s STILL the best!
Lennys of Jamesport has the best Grandma pie!
Michelangelo’s in Cutchogue for your traditional NYC pizza or Granna in Jamesport for neopolitan style pizza
Michelangelo’s of Mattituck
Grana on Main Rd., Jamesport , blows away all your typical commercial pizzas offered on the East End. Opened since the spring of 2010, they have already received excellent reviews from the NY Times, Newsday and other magazines – for their delicious Artisanal Wood Fired Brick Oven Pizzas, made with high quality ingrediants. Cute cafe also offers delicious salads (local produce) and other tasty items. I have no affiliation here other than being a regular customer. I add, owners and staff are also very pleasant. Lastly, they recently received their wine & beer license. Mangia !
Cheesy Charlie’s in Southold
Lenny’s in Jamesport. First place we visit when we return for a visit ~ live in GA now and there is NOTHING that compares to NY pizza!
Cheesy Charlies, in southold
la capricciosa
(brick oven) in Greenport
Lenny’s is by far the ultimat pizza on the Entire East End.
I like Grana – it’s a great NYC/New Haven style pie, and they have really, really good specials. We’re locals and have Grana at least once a week.
GRANA’S IN JAMESPORT! Best best best!!
Brick oven ‘Greenport (of course)
Pagano’s in Southold. Good ingredients, Fair prices, friendly staff.
I miss my Long Island pizza and I’d like to vote for 2 places…Pagano’s in Southold & Michelangelo’s in Cutchogue. Michelangelo’s has the BEST buffalo chicken pizza and Pagano’s has always been the favorite for “walking downtown during lunch period” in high school!
Tthe Original Umberto’s of New Hyde Park (on Jericho Tpke.)!
Village Pizza in Mattituck
Definitely lenny’s !
GRANA’S IN JAMESPORT! -Hand’s down. Not only the best but the freshest ingredients, using local vendors and they have the most amazing creations!! Totally worth the 2+ hour drive from Jersey!
Pagano’s and Michaelangelo’s and Lenny’s are all incredible. I almost rate them equally because anyone can have a really good day or a not-so-great day.
The Sicilian in Mattituck! Always Great pizza and whoever the new guy is Pizza was even BETTER!!
Cheesy Charlie’s, southold
The new guy I think is the best pizza maker on the east end,much better than the presant owner.
Lenny’s use to be a good pizza but has gon way down hill in the last 6 monthe,the food olso has gon down hill,not a good cheff in the kitchen.
Your taste buds must be out to lunch.
I think Michelangelo’s has a commercial tasting Pizza,just like frozen from the market.
Cheesy Charlie’s Pizza in Southold. No one else compares!