02.01.2014 Real Estate Spaces: The historic Ira Tuthill House in Mattituck By Rachel Young Share on Facebook Facebook Created with Sketch. Share on Twitter Twitter Created with Sketch. Share via email Mail Created with Sketch. The main house that anchors that Mattituck-Laurel Historical Society campus on Main Road is now a spacious colonial. But in 1799, the year it was built by Jesse Tuthill, the residence contained just two rooms. Read more on northforker.com.