10/16/13 4:19pm
10/16/2013 4:19 PM
KATHARINE SCHROEDER PHOTO | Town board candidates debate winery regulation and deer management during Tuesday's forum.

KATHARINE SCHROEDER PHOTO | Town board candidates debate winery regulation and deer management during Tuesday’s forum.

Town finances, winery regulations and deer management were among the issues discussed at a Southold Town Board candidates forum sponsored by The Suffolk Times and hosted at Peconic Landing in Greenport Tuesday night.

Democratic challengers Mary Eisenstein and Ron Rothman asked voters to elect a different voice to the all-Republican board, while incumbent Town Board member Jim Dinizio, a registered Conservative, and Republican challenger and current town Trustee Bob Ghosio touted their experience and working knowledge of the issues facing Southold.

Here’s what the candidates had to say about the issues:


When it comes to Southold Town’s current deer management plan, Democratic hopefuls said there is none.

Mary Eisenstein, who has been diagnosed with Lyme disease four times during her 21 years on the North Fork, said the Town Board hasn’t been working hard enough to lobby Albany for more effective means of controlling the deer population.

“If I’m on the board, the first thing I’m doing is getting a busload of people to go to Albany,” she said.

The Republican candidates agreed deer management is a major issue in Southold Town. Mr. Ghosio pointed to Assemblyman Robert Sweeney (D-Lindenhurst) for letting legislation that would relax hunting regulations in Suffolk County and across the state to stall in committee.

“The problem is we are ready to address it, but the state is not,” Mr. Ghosio said. He believes when the North Fork’s vacant state Assembly seat is filled in November, Southold’s deer management issue will be better represented and more progress will be made. All the candidates said they would support Republican Town Supervisor Scott Russell’s proposal to allocate $75,000 in the 2014 town budget toward deer management.


Every candidate spoke in favor of Mr. Russell’s proposed budget for 2013-14 and supported the way the town manages its finances.

The proposed $41.6 million 2014 spending plan includes a 1 percent spending increase over the current year and would result in a 1.17 percent tax hike.

Mr. Dinizio said the town does a good job of limiting expenses and spending wisely, citing the Town Board’s recent authorization of a $3.5 million bond for construction improvements to the town’s highway facility. The proposed upgrades include demolition of existing fuel storage tanks and construction of a consolidated fueling station, he said.The consolidation would allow the town to store more fuel in the event of a natural disaster like superstorm Sandy.

“There are places were you can spend money to gain efficiency,” Mr. Dinizio said.

Democrats agreed the current Town Board handles its finances well.

“It is a well-managed town,” said Democrat Ron Rothman. “We are fiscally in good shape.”

Ms. Eisenstein said, “As I’m out speaking with people, they say how they like how Scott Russell manages our town and I concur with that.”

She agreed with Mr. Dinizio’s suggestion that the town could gain efficiency.


Any discussion on how to strike a balance between meeting the needs of agricultural businesses and maintaining the rural character of Southold Town will eventually turn to Vineyard 48’s controversial business practices. Tuesday’s debate was no exception.

The Cutchogue vineyard’s business practices have prompted investigations by both the town and the State Liquor Authority following a host of complaints, including reports of loud music and patrons allegedly wandering onto neighboring properties and engaging in illicit behavior.

While board members have traditionally taken a strong stance against the vineyard, Democratic hopeful Mr. Rothman said the winery is being stifled by the town’s excessive legislation, pointing specifically to the newly enacted special events law.The law and the winery use review were a response to residents’ complaints about such events — most notably at Vineyard 48 — and concern about the town’s options in addressing code violations.

Mr. Rothman, owner of Rothman’s Department Store in Southold, said the town should have enforced the laws already on the books rather then passing new regulations to restrict all of the town’s agricultural businesses.

“It’s overkill for the problem,” Mr. Rothman said. “I’m for agriculture and promoting the businesses that are zoned for these area. It is a good-neighbor policy.”

Mr. Dinizo said the need for the legislation stems from some operations not following a “good-neighbor policy.”

“If you mention [Vineyard] 48 you have to mention what goes on there; this establishment breaks the law every week,” he said. “That is a safety problem and a police problem.”

Mr. Dinizio, who has served for more than two decades on various Southold Town boards, said he’s seen the town’s need for more extensive regulations grow.

“In 1988 it was cheese and crackers and sipping wine and it was fine, but things are changing and that’s why we have a Town Board so we can all sleep at night,” he said.

Viewing the issue on a broader scale, Mr. Ghosio said his priority was to maintain the rural charm of the town.

“Riverhead used to be a rural town and we all see what’s happening out west and we don’t want that to happen here,” he said. “If we need to create laws to maintain that from time to time, so be it.”

[email protected]

10/26/12 4:41pm
10/26/2012 4:41 PM

SUFFOLK TIMES FILE PHOTO | Supervisor Scott Russell

Southold Town Supervisor Scott Russell said Friday that a discussion on the 2013 town budget scheduled for Monday night has been rescheduled for Thursday, Nov. 1 at 7 p.m. at the Peconic Lane Community Center due to the impending storm.

Mr. Russell said Southold will decide tomorrow, Oct. 27, whether to open town emergency shelters during the storm. If so, an announcement will be posted on the town’s website and will be covered on this site

He said Suffolk County plans to open three shelters, in Hampton Bays, Brentwood and Sachem, and a shelter for people with special needs at the John J. Foley Skilled Nursing Facility in Yaphank.

“Everybody’s been activated to stay ready,” he said.

09/21/12 4:55pm
09/21/2012 4:55 PM

TIM KELLY FILE PHOTO | Supervisor Scott Russell delivering his “State of the Town” address earlier this year.

Supervisor Scott Russell has proposed a new Southold town budget with total spending of just under $41 million and an accompanying property tax rate increase of 1.98 percent.

Although that figure seems just barely within the state’s 2 percent tax cap, the rate includes mandated payments including contributions to the state employee retirement system that are not covered by the 2 percent cap.

The budget now goes to the full Town Board for its review.

Click on the link below to read the supervisor’s budget message.


09/07/12 7:00pm
09/07/2012 7:00 PM

Although state law prohibits the town and other local taxing authorities from raising the property tax levy more than 2 percent in any one year, Southold Town could see a tax rate hike approaching 3 percent in 2013, said Supervisor Scott Russell, who must submit a new spending plan outline by the end of this month.

Several economic factors, all unfavorable, are the cause, Mr. Russell said.

Town employee pension payments alone will rise $277,000 over this year’s level, he said.

That will add a full percentage point to the tax rate hike. Pension costs do not count toward the 2 percent limit.

While that expense continues to rise, the town’s mortgage tax revenue continues to be far below past levels. When real estate sales are booming, that funding can approach $7 million a year and even in an average year the town can expect to take in between $4 million and $5 million, Mr. Russell said.

Next year he expects the town will received under $1 million.

“It should come as no surprise to anyone that the economic conditions have not improved and the outlook remains bleak,” Mr. Russell said.

This year’s town budget raised property taxes 2.2 percent.

[email protected]

Read the complete story in the Sept. 13 issue of The Suffolk Times.