Hanover Bank bets on local ties as it settles into Riverhead
A new bank that opened its doors in Riverhead last month is making an early investment in its neighbors — donating $5,000 to two nonprofits serving at-risk youth and local families.
Hanover Bank gave $2,500 each to Timothy Hill Ranch and Family Community Life Center. Its chairman and CEO, Michael Puorro, says community ties are central to the lender’s plans for the East End.
“Every dollar of our deposit, every dollar of our profitability gets totally reinvested right back into the communities that we serve,” Mr. Puorro said at the bank’s Oct. 29 grand-opening celebration, where he and president Kevin O’Connor handed out the oversized checks.
In a recent interview with the Riverhead News-Review, he described an opportunity to serve contractors, farmers and smaller businesses he says bigger banks often overlook — and help finance downtown Riverhead’s redevelopment.
The Riverhead branch, which opened in October, occupies ground-floor space in The East End apartment building at 205 Osborn Ave. It is Hanover’s 11th location and third in Suffolk County, joining Hauppauge and Port Jefferson.

A gap in local banking
Riverhead was once the home base of four publicly chartered banks, including Suffolk County National Bank, Riverhead Savings Bank, Suffolk County Trust Company and Long Island State Bank and Trust Company.
Those institutions were absorbed into other banks over several decades.
“It’s been a complete transformation,” Mr. Puorro said. “They’re all gone, so you don’t have the banks that know the customers’ needs and know the local demographic.”
Mr. Puorro called that loss an “unfortunate” development, but said it creates an opportunity for Hanover to offer lending tailored to the East End.
The bank focuses on commercial real estate, commercial and industrial business lending, small-business loans, residential lending and municipal deposits. Borrowers who might be “too small” for larger banks are among those Hanover wants to serve, he said.
“It’s us against the big guys, that we can do very well against,” the Hanover CEO said. “You don’t have the locally-owned, headquartered community commercial banks here anymore — the last one, you’re talking to.”
Plans for Riverhead
Riverhead had been on Hanover’s radar for nearly two years, Mr. Puorro said. He cited downtown redevelopment and the Suffolk County Center as draws, describing the town’s potential as a “regional hub.”
“We’re going to play a significant role in all facets of redevelopment, including construction, commercial real estate, and small-business financing,” the CEO said.
Customers meet with representatives in offices or a conference room. There is no traditional teller line, and routine transactions are automated — creating an “Apple store” look, Mr. Puorro said.
Mr. Puorro said local decision-making and hiring employees familiar with the communities they serve are central to Hanover’s approach. Customers might see bank employees at dinner, at the grocery store or at church, he said.
The community bank says its mission is to provide commercial and personal banking products and personalized financial services. Those include 24-hour ATM service, free interest-bearing checking, telephone banking, mobile and online banking, and safe deposit boxes. Its banking services also include multifamily and commercial mortgages, residential loans, business loans and lines of credit.
The Riverhead branch joins the bank’s Long Island locations in Hauppauge and Port Jefferson. Mr. Puorro said the Riverhead branch represents a significant milestone in Hanover Bank’s long-term expansion across Suffolk County and the greater New York metropolitan area.
From turnaround to expansion
In its early years, Hanover Community Bank was undercapitalized and hit hard by the financial crisis, Mr. Puorro recalled.
The turning point came in 2012, when “life began for Hanover,” he said. With a group of investors, he recapitalized the bank and reconstituted its board and management. Profitability improved within a year, he said.
At that point, Hanover had about $57 million in assets, $2 million in equity and 13 employees, Mr. Puorro said. After raising additional capital and completing two acquisitions, its parent company, Hanover Bancorp, went public in May 2022, pricing its initial public offering at $21 per share and beginning trading on the Nasdaq Global Select Market.
“It brought in new shareholders, institutional shareholders, which is very important to an up-and-coming growth story of a public company,” Mr. Puorro told the Riverhead News-Review.
Hanover reported $2.44 billion in assets as of Sept. 30. Its stock, which trades under the symbol HNVR, closed at $21.69 on Nov. 17.
Mr. Puorro said the bank now employs about 180 people.
Looking ahead, Hanover is considering additional banking centers in the Hamptons or along Long Island’s South Shore, Mr. Puorro said.
“We measure our success based on the success of our customer base,” he said.

