News

Southold woman, 92, seeks good Samaritan who returned her wallet

A 92-year-old Southold woman is giving thanks just after Thanksgiving after a young stranger knocked on her door to return her wallet — before she even knew it was missing.

Joan Mathie was putting away freshly cleaned clothes Nov. 3 when the young man arrived. His brief introduction left her with two clues for finding him: a first name and a connection to Reydon Shores, a waterfront community on Great Hog Neck in Southold.

“All he said was, ‘I found your wallet,’” Ms. Mathie said. “‘My name is Stephen. I’m living in Reydon Shores.’ That’s all he said.”

He left before she could invite him in for coffee or properly express her appreciation.

“I wanted to go after him. He just kind of went right down the front stoop, got in the car, and went away,” she recalled during a visit to The Suffolk Times newsroom in Mattituck shortly after her encounter with the good Samaritan.

Earlier that afternoon, Ms. Mathie had driven to King Kullen in Cutchogue for groceries and stopped at the cleaners next door to pick up her laundry. She had her hands full, carrying both her wallet and her nine newly cleaned shirts and pants. With the clothes draped over her shoulder, she carried them back to her car, tossing them all into her trunk and assuming her wallet was with them.

She drove home, started to put the clothes away, and that’s when the knock came.

“I had no idea it was gone,” she said.

Ms. Mathie said her “whole life” is in her wallet, including the keys to her safe deposit box.

Her search for the mystery do-gooder follows a similar effort by Southold veteran John Christina, who reunited with the woman who surprised him and another veteran with $50 Costco gift cards after The Suffolk Times helped track her down.

Ms. Mathie said Stephen’s gesture had restored her faith in society.

“He’s shown me an example of good people who are thinking about their neighbors,” she said. “I’ve just been upset myself because I have not said thank you to someone. We have wonderful people in this world who do wonderful things.”

Stephen, or anyone who knows him, is asked to contact The Suffolk Times at [email protected] so we can help put him in touch with Ms. Mathie.