Guest Spot

Guest Column: Managing the North Fork housing crisis

Spaniards are rioting over housing costs. Canadians are demanding a constitutional right to housing. Colombians fault their government for neglecting their housing needs after the recent earthquake. The worldwide crisis is real — and it’s urgent.

In Southold, we are not immune. The K-shaped economy of our tiny corner of the world, where high-rollers prosper and regular workers suffer, is driving young people and families away and deterring new settlers. And we are not doing enough, fast enough, to counter the trend.

Two recent housing forums hosted by CAST, sponsored by civic association volunteers and covered by this paper lifted the voices of people who need housing, whether for themselves or for their employees and colleagues. They also showed us some of what we can do to take small steps in the right direction — make it easy for homeowners to add a small house on a suitable property, support the Housing Alliance programs for low-income residents and, most important, invest in low-rise, multi-family development projects that look and feel like the Southold we know.

It would be unfair to suggest that Southold Town and the Village of Greenport are not moving in these directions. The town is engaged in a careful and comprehensive process of code changes that will enable mixed-use development in the centers of several of its hamlets. The village is also debating zoning reform that would provide incentives to liven up the downtown and legalize accessory dwelling units (ADUs), which Southold already permits. Town staff has prepared a schedule for spending the Community Housing Fund, the golden goose for supporting what is accessible to ordinary folks. The fund has grown to more than $8.5 million since its approval by voters in 2023.

But none of this is happening soon enough to dispel a sense among the general public and businesspeople alike that in Southold and Greenport you can’t get anything done. And the scale of what is proposed does not approach the need.

Consider the following:

  • At least two proposals for multi-family housing are languishing — one for more than two years — in a kind of governmental storage bin in Southold without serious internal review or public hearing. Taken together, these projects could serve more than 30 households.
  • The Village of Greenport owns a substantial property on the North Road that could be developed with multi-family housing — perhaps as many as 25 units. The parcel, however, is under the zoning authority of the town, which has been unwilling to permit the village to do anything with it. It’s not quite taxation without representation, but close.
  • Two years ago Greenport began a process of considering code changes that would accomplish many of the objectives mentioned in the recent housing forum about solutions to the housing crisis. The package of zoning reforms that the village Planning Board detailed and recommended to the Board of Trustees — with some review by the village housing committee — has been stuck in legal review since May without any public input (possibly in violation of the Public Meetings Law).

Of course, there are problems with moving these and other projects along: lawsuits that linger, Southold planning staff shortages, NIMBY as a political barrier. But some of these could be overcome if there was a true sense of urgency.

It is beyond the scope of this essay to opine on why we are not driven to be bold in this moment. But it bears repeating that we are threatened by the loss of a community that is healthy, vibrant and balanced if we don’t find and create places to live for all people who give it those qualities. As community housing advisor Michael Daly says, “We must invest in human infrastructure.”


Diana Gordon is chair of the workforce and affordable housing committee of Greenport Village.